The general branch of the College of Law / University of Karbala conducted a seminar to discuss a doctoral thesis project submitted by a graduate student (Awatif Alaeddin Abd) and tagged (the rationality of criminal policy: a comparative study). The scientific committee in public law discussed the research project and expressed its directives to the student. It also made some substantive modifications in the methodology of scientific research and some others in the research plan and the origin of the research topic. It also discussed the fundamental issue in the research. Detectives that have been allocated to it in a sound systematic manner.